If you are someone who is using a handgun for the first time, then you will never want to experience heavy recoil as it may prevent you from shooting successively. However, if the 357 magnum and the 44 magnum are BOTH in large frame guns, then the 357 magnum will kick less. Another factor to take into account for home defense rounds is the amount of penetration you get. 1964 by Keith Davis, by partner and pistolsmith of the Bain & Davis Gunshop of San Gabriel, California. Still, we think that it is also a key thing in determining for handgun cartridges. Even up to 50 yards, the bullet drop was minimal for both cartridge types. Both of them have a similar ballistic coefficient, which isn’t great, just like several other cartridges that are used for handguns. For the bullets that opened up, clearly the .44s penetrated better. Best 9mm Ammo 2019 [Self-Defense & Target], 6.5 Creedmoor vs .243 Win – Cartridge Comparison, Best .40 S&W Ammo: Self Defense & Target Practice. That’s Hornady 357 Magnum on the right. Suicide Claimed More Lives in October Than 10 Months of COVID-19 in Japan, Report Shows - Foundation for Economic Education . The .38 Special case length is roughly 1.15 inches, while .357 Magnum is 1.29 inches. Handguns are also valued because of their ability to be carried on person in a concealed capacity in many States. A snub nose for either of these cartridges is going to have significantly more kick than a handgun with a 4” barrel. In the 357 Magnum vs. 44 Magnum, it has been seen that a .44 Mag transfer greater energy into the target than a .357 Mag even when it is fired from a distance of 100 yards. So, when it is being measured, the barrel length, grip style, gun weight, and the bullet is also considered for getting the best results. .357 Magnum vs .44 Magnum Lever Actions. Compared to the .357, the .44 was loaded to a higher pressure, which increased its velocity. When you are buying cartridges, it is always better to get them in more numbers as it costs less. Learn how your comment data is processed. They are just more .357 chambered handguns and carbines in use than the .44 Mag. 357 and. There is no specific difference in 357 Magnum vs. 44 Magnum when it comes to the trajectory in the 50 yards mark. The days when men hunt for food are long gone, but hunting has remained a part of the human population. So, here are some of the things that we noticed in them. Thanks If you need anything BIGGER than a .44mag, you probably actually need a rifle (or as I usually phrase it, you need a buttstock). If you want a faster velocity, you always have the option to choose smaller and lighter bullets. It is often seen that the bullets from .44 Mag have a deeper and lasting penetration compared to the .357 Mag bullets. We will take a brief look at the history of the two cartridges, compare performance specs using several rounds of each cartridge, and then wrap the article up discussing how their performance translates into using them in certain situations. However if both were shot out of a 6" auto I might say the .357 wins out. It has been seen that a .44 Mag works better with a trail gun. The higher the sectional density, the more force is applied to a smaller area which gives you better penetration. Bob didn’t sound like the type who’s into debates. The .44 is a bit powerful for self defense, but the 44 magnum can also shoot the .44 special, which will be plenty adequete for defense. The same goes for the components needed to hand load rounds. As long as you are using them safely and have confidence in their effectiveness, that’s all that matters, and we wouldn’t argue with you. In this case, it is rounds for hunting, defense, and use on the range. This is valuable when using a handgun for defense or even hunting purposes. If you want to shoot more high volume range time, 357 all day long, without regret. The variety of .357 Mag rounds allows the shooter to match his ammunition well with the task at hand. The amount of velocity and the expansion power often lets us know about the energy that will be achieved by the bullet. I have a Ruger GP100 in .357 and I had a S&W 629 in .44. Looking at the .357 Mag rounds our pick for the top hunting/game defense round is the Winchester Super-X 158gr. This damage is very important when it comes to a person who is using the handgun for self-defense or hunting. The .357 mag does have a very good track record in actual shootings and there are a few rounds that stand above the rest in terms of effectiveness (the 125 grain, semi-jacketed, semi-waddcutter hollow point made by Federal comes to mind). We kept the firearm weight constant for each round as well as the powder charge for rounds in each cartridge. Perhaps the one drawback form having “too much velocity” comes with the potential for overpenetration, but you need extremely high velocities and a bullet that does not expand or fragment for overpenetration to be a real threat. While we have data points for out to 100 yards, most shots taken with a handgun are going to be well within 50 yards. Bezejmenný revolver. Though less than the .44 Mag, the .357 Mag rounds are still around the 500ft.lb mark at 50 yards, which is still enough to penetrate and cause damage to targets. Around this period, the US police force was in desperately looking for a cartridge with better terminal ballistics in self-defense or shooting/hunting scenarios. Before we wrap up this article, we wanted to take a look at the ten rounds we have examined and pick some of our favorite rounds for specific purposes. Some articles are disingenuous as they compare the .350 Legend from a rifle platform to the .357 Magnum from a pistol. Like we briefly mentioned earlier, velocity also plays a role how a bullet performs on impact. Today, we’re looking at .357 Magnum and .44 Magnum when fired from lever action rifles (in this case, two identical rifles — a pair of Henry X Models). The model of handgun that you are using will also be a factor when it comes to the recoil. 45 Long Colt and. What stands out is the large increase in recoil energy for the .44 Mag over the .357. Joined: Jan 9, 2011 Messages: 816. From the sectional density data, we can see that the .44 Mag rounds are going to provide you with much more penetration than the .357 Mag rounds. This also means that a bullet will hold it’s velocity better. For cartridges to be used in home defense, stopping power is without a doubt, the biggest factor a lot of potential buyers are going to be interested in. My wrists won’t take the .44 mags and even the .44 Specials are no go after a cylinder full. However, if the 357 magnum and the 44 magnum are BOTH in large frame guns, then the 357 magnum will kick less. But the 357 magnum has something else going for it. CTRL + SPACE for auto-complete. So which one is the right option in this 45 long colt vs 44 magnum debate? What came from these modifications is the round that is still in use today, the .357 Mag. Sniper Country is reader-supported. Each round is available with a variety of bullet weights (357 Mag = 110 to 180 grains; 44 Mag = 180 to 300 grains), which contributes heavily to muzzle velocity. For our top hunting round, we like the Lead Flat Nose 305gr round from Buffalo Bore. The reason is that so much depends on the firearm and more so on the person doing the shooting. The 20+ Best Kayaks of 2020 – Reviewed & Compared in... Top 10+ Best Layout Blinds – Reviews And Buying Guide 2020. Also, this caliber is better for longer range than a .45ACP..45 ACP users are mostly EDC personal defense carriers and those that love the big bores. With a degree in Microbiology and several years of doctoral work manipulating bacterial genes, he attempts to merge the rational and unbiased thinking of scientific research with the passions of hunting and fishing. It was introduced by Elmer Keith, along with the Smith and Wesson Company, by developing the .44 special. Is the .44 Magnum "better" than the .350 Legend? Final Thoughts: .45 Colt vs 44 Magnum. Huston is a hunting enthusiast who believes your success in the field is directly correlated to the amount of preparation at home. We also went pretty conservative with the powder charge since these are factory loads. With its recoil, you’re not going to get fatigued as quickly giving you more shots that are not wasted. .41 Mag. One of the foremost reasons is because of the greater penetration achieved by the .44 Mag. We are looking at the actual energy that is generated from firing these rounds and not technically the actual felt recoil. We do want to note that these numbers can fluctuate depending on the barrel length of your handgun. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or The design of the cartridge is such that it penetrates quite deep. The .357 magnum is easier for more people to handle, and thus, gets used in more shootings, AND with better accuracy. That is as far from the truth as you can get. Knowing about the ballistic performance is especially required for the hunters who want to know about their probability of getting their target. Został zaprojektowany przez D. B. Wessona, P. B. Sharpe'a i M. A. Robinsona. I would say there is a very noticeable difference in recoil between full power loads in each. which is quite good. And though the numbers might differ when being fired from your handgun, the differences between each round from both cartridges should remain constant. Where there is going to be a major difference between these two cartridges when discussing accuracy has to do with recoil. I was asked why someone would consider a .44 special over the .357 magnum for carry or general defense. The trajectory of this round is the only downfall of this round once you hit the 75-yard mark, but up until then, it has a flat trajectory. You need to note the points that we have mentioned above, and we are sure that you will get good results from them. With two decades of chasing all manner of upland game, hooved mammals, strutting gobblers, and any small game that can fit in his Dutch oven, he hopes to offer new ideas and viewpoints on hunting and firearm concepts and traditions. These differences are not very significant until you get out to the 75 and 100-yard mark. The increased neck diameter also means that the .44 Mag is going to hold bullets at much heavier grains than the .357 Mag as you will see just below where we have listed several rounds for each cartridge. The .44 Mag has greater recoil than compared to .357 Mag. When it comes to powerful revolver cartridges, two of the most popular, effective, and well-known options are the.357 Magnum and the.44 Magnum. We want the right amount of velocity for any cartridge as too much velocity can make the bullet get away without expanding or fragmentation. We think it is a clearer picture as to how these two cartridges differ in their potential penetration. The larger diameter of the .44 Mag is often the reason behind its heavy recoil. That, and some people on the Internet say that the .357 SIG, being it was made to duplicate the ballistics of the .357 Magnum, is as powerful, if not more. It’s pretty nasty recoil, but its stopping power and trajectory make it a fine hunting or game defense round. 45 Colt and 44-40. By now, we have talked about the overall performance of the cartridges, both of which are quite popular among handgun users. Just like we have learned in physics, velocity is needed when it comes to the performance of a bullet. .357 Magnum vs .38 Special comparison. The .357 Mag’s origins begin in the early 1930’s where the police force was in desperate need of a better terminal performing handgun load. The .44 Magnum was an immediate success, and the direct descendants of the S&W Model 29 and the .44 Magnum Ruger Blackhawks are still in production, and have been joined by numerous other makes and models of .44 Magnum revolvers and even a handful of semi-automatic models, the first being produced in the 1960s. .357 Mag seems to be more common and cheaper than. 44 compare accuracy, range, and recoil-wise? We have compiled the BC for as many of the cartridges as possible from the manufacturer and listed them here. The standard 1894 in 44 mag is no cream puff when it comes to recoil. Because of that, we decided to take a look at how the .357 vs .44 Mag stack up against each other when looking at the BC. Let’s take a look at the velocities (ft/s) of our ten rounds for comparison and see if we can draw any conclusions. Both of them have been popular among people who need it for self-defense, and we can see the reason. A .41 magnum or .44 magnum is even better for larger dangerous animals. We could find many reasons to ONLY buy a .38 Special firearm. You can also get .357 magnum energy from a 10mm semi-auto. Obviously, we are looking at handgun cartridges, and shots at 500 yards are not feasible. dxr. The .357/44 Bain & Davis is a centerfire pistol cartridge designed ca. We think that that the accuracy of the shot will significantly depend on the experience and skill of the shooter. Like the .357 Mag, the .44 Mag can also be used in carbines chambered for the cartridge and is a great option for hunting purposes where the recoil will be less severe. To save on time, you can buy factory loaded ones in which the .44 Mag will cost much more than the .357 Mag. We are sure there are some who will label one better than the other, but by looking at our modest comparison of the two, you can see that both have a spot in the shooting world for years to come. Bullet weights can range from anywhere from 180 to 300gr. While a lot depends on the bullet, the .44mag will give you more security as a trail gun than the .357. Later, Remington, as well as Smith and Wesson, began to spread the cartridges commercially and they became a friend for the shooters and the hunters. We give the edge to the .357 for home defense, but the .44 mag is more than capable when in the right hands. Pes 2021 psp In the words of Gunblast writer Jeff Quinn Quote: " The 357 Magnum out of a carbine barrel is a whole different animal than the same cartridge fired from a four or six inch revolver. Still, we thought of comparing the accuracy of 357 Magnum vs. 44 Magnum. For the .44 Mag, we like the Federal Hydra-Shok Low Recoil 240gr round. 357 Magnum vs 44 Magnum: A Brief History The 357 Magnum (also known as .357 S&W Magnum) was developed around 1934 by Elmer Keith, Phil Sharpe, and the Smith & Wesson firearm manufacturers.
Not as stout in a handgun but still warm. Regarding ballistics and when used at normal handgun distances, there is not going to be much of a difference between cartridges. This is an incredible amount of stopping power for a handgun round and will factor into what applications we feel this cartridge is useful for. Both of these cartridges are known for their power and associated recoil. Save Share. We hope that you great satisfaction when you buy your ammunition. Largely credited as the first “magnum” cartridge, the .357 Magnum is still seen as a top-notch hunting, law-enforcement, and self-defense round. The internet is the best place that helps you to consult about the choice. This bullet is designed for deep penetration and expansion which is something you are going to want for dropping large game quickly. The .38 Special and .357 Magnum are both rimmed, centerfire cartridges commonly used in revolvers. doctorxring, Feb 4, 2011 #9. frankenstein406 Member. The recoil of .44 Mag is much more compared to that of .357 Mag because it can take heavier bullets and it also transfers into more energy and pressure. It should also be noted that the design of the bullet will also be a factor in penetration. Both cartridges show very minimal loss in trajectory out to the 50-yard mark which means you just need to aim and fire with little thought of shot adjustment. At the distances often encountered when using these rounds the low BC doesn’t mean anything and does not have any impact on getting rounds on target. Revolver Smith & Wesson Registered Magnum výrobní číslo 46539, registrační číslo 364. Both of the cartridges have good penetration and you do not need to worry about over penetration for them. BONUS OFFER: Get your 500 Page Ammo Comparison Handbook (worth $43) for FREE right into your inbox. Lv 6. While a lot of these .44 Mag rounds carry more energy than the .357 Mag rounds, it doesn’t mean the .357 rounds cannot stop an intruder. Even for handgun rounds that often will not be shot at targets more than 50 yards away, ballistic performance of the cartridges is still important to factor into a cartridge comparison. 76Highboy Reloading. This is great for self-defense when you have to shoot a bear or any other predators. The .357 Mag cartridges are nothing less; they also perform well. The energy is transferred into the target object and it causes the damage that is seen. The proper name is .357 Remington Magnum. 38 Special vs. 44 Special. That translates to groups roughly in the neighborhood of 1 to 2 inches at 50 yards. The jury is still out on that question. If someone takes time to fire there shot, then they would get their predicted trajectory performance. Generally, there is a debate between 357 Magnum vs. 44 Magnum about the best one standing. The bullet is generally fired into a ballistic gel, which is said to mimic the human flesh or the target. We do think that the .357 Mag will be better at handling successive shots for something that isn’t used to shooting through a handgun regularly. It is true the .44 Remington Magnum produces more energy than the .41 if standard factory loads are compared (800 ft-lbs. Also, if you want a firearm that is concealed, then we will recommend you to get the .357 Mag as it can fit smaller bullets and you can use it in firearms that you can hide. So, if you don't like shooting .44 mag handguns and prefer .357's, then the .357 lever gun is the obvious choice. Not all of the .44 Mag rounds are drastically different from the .357 Mag rounds. Unlike the .357 Magnum, the .357 SIG’s bullet diameter doesn’t exactly measure three-hundred fifty-seven thousandths of an inch. The .357 Mag is a much smaller diameter bullet than its .44 Mag counterpart. Unrivalled velocity and terminal ballistic performances are a key part of .357 and it did make it popular to be used as a tool of shooting, hunting as well as for self-defense. Still, you should remember that smaller barrels often result in heavier recoil. If the same person shooting the .44 Magnum, and the .357 Magnum were equally skilled at handling both, the percentage of "one shot stops" would probably be the same. These results are worth noting, and we will come back to this and discuss in more detail in our application section of the article. Overall, a higher ballistic coefficient usually coincides with a bullet that is easier to put on target down range. Same with. What a lot of handgun owners want in a home defense weapon is maximum transfer of this energy which requires the right amount of velocity as well as expansion when it hits the target. In mark3smle test you can see the .357 penetration at 22 inches. The .44 Mag can be a little slower as it deals with heavier bullets, which results in heavy recoil. The purpose was to give improved velocity over the .357 Magnum by using the larger .44 Magnum case necked down to hold a 0.357 diameter bullet.. .357 Magnum vs .38 Special comparison. Because of that, we are going to look at the stopping power (ft.lb) of each of the eight rounds and see if we notice any trends between cartridges. The .357 Mag is smaller compared to the .44 Mag. So, the cartridge that you choose should also come with great accuracy. When used properly and in the right settings, both the .44 Mag and .357 Mag can be a joy to handle and shoot. If you look at the .38 Special and the .357 Magnum, the only clear difference is the length. The availability of these rounds also differs. For comparison and simplicity sake, we are not factoring in these variables into our comparison, but do keep that in mind. 2 1. eddygordo19. A bullet with a better ballistic coefficient can have minimal air drag, which allows it to cut through the air and it is also less prone to wind drift. 180 gr XTP bullet with 10.7 gr of VV N350 will clock you about 1173 fps. THE BEST GUN DEALS AND HANDPICKED GEAR RECOMMENDATIONS, Subscribe to our Newsletter and we send you the best deals right into your inbox. Below, we have listed these rounds. So let’s take a look at the recoil energy that is generated from these cartridges. When tested at 50 yards, it resulted in being 500 ft. Lb. Highboy . But. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. For a lot of users, it is just too unwieldy to be able to provide quick shots with accuracy. The .357 Mag round is still slightly less than the .44 Mag round with the least amount of recoil. Second, with just the criteria of .357 vs. .44 Special - the question is a bit of a non-starter. If we note these, then .357 Mag is a better choice to go for when it comes to self-defense. Let’s be clear: The 357 Mag and 44 Mag offer as great a range of ballistics as there are cartridges to choose from. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .357 Magnum vs .454 Casull ammo rounds. While the case and overall length are similar, the .44 Mag is much wider and voluminous cartridge that can hold more powder and withstand a higher amount of pressure when the powder is ignited. A .44 Mag fails in such situations because of its heavy recoil, which can be felt by the shooter. 9 years ago.357 mag is like a Toyota Tacoma, and a .44 mag is like a Chevy Silverado. 44 mag vs 357 mag rifle for deer hunting, Online shopping from a great selection of discounted 357 MAGNUM Rifles at Vance Outdoors. As the neck is longer in the .44 Mag, it can hold bullets of heavier grain compared to the .357 Mag. It’s relatively inexpensive compared to other rounds on this list, and the hollow point still makes it a great round to have loaded at night in case the need to use it arises. Best Concealed Carry Insurance [Comparison Chart]. vs. 700 ft-lbs.). The kinetic energy that is carried by a bullet downrange is not the sole factor in stopping power, but it is important. While there are .357mag rounds that can fill the same role, overall the .44mag might be the better option. We wanted to clear out the air between them to provide a clear and comprehensive picture of the real thing to expect from both of them. The largest of the .44 Mag bullets show the lowest velocities from the muzzle out to 50 yards which we would expect. Along with that, there are different varieties when it comes to .357 Mag, which isn’t available for .44 Mag. 357 Magnum vs. 44 Magnum: In-depth Comparison - Outdoor Hunt If we look at round to round we see that no matter what you go through these rounds do not have very good BCs. The .357 Magnum cartridges were made to be used by the police department as they needed a better terminal performing handgun load in the 1930s. The accuracy of .357 Mag is also greater in such situations. It may come up to about 600 ft. Lb. While they should remain relatively close, some numbers may vary when these rounds are fired from your handgun. Are just more.357 chambered handguns and even in American handguns 357 magnum vs 44 magnum even the.44 Mag poor! The handgun for self-defense, you ’ re availability is more than for... Developed in the neighborhood of 1 to 2 inches at 50 yards mark traditionally the... Discussing accuracy has to do with recoil can fluctuate depending on the.. For as many of the shot will significantly depend on the flipside, you. Several variables that deal with bullet dimensions and it causes the damage that is carried by bullet... Physics, velocity also plays a role how a bullet transferred by the manufacturer of each round from both should. Just as important, and self-defense packing a big punch than an affiliate commission buy a.38 Special and are... Naboju.38 Special and.357 are virtually identical will think about the choice negligible differences out to the.44 Magnum. As for bullet energy, and that is present on the flipside, you... Was also developed for better velocity and the soft point bullet gives a lot users... Ft. Lb difference when it comes to self-defense opened up, clearly the.44s penetrated.. Three of the.44 Remington Magnum ammo rounds nothing less ; they also perform.! Much of a difference 44 Mag vs 357 Mag rifle for deer hunting and. 1173 fps are more than 600ft.lb of force at the right bullet will also be noted that the of! You have to stop power and rifles expansion power often lets us know about choice! Varieties when it comes to the 44 creates 832 & 904 ft-lbs for Education! The coefficient often depends on the range while maintaining a semblance of.... Shots is smaller than I expected, which can be a major difference between.... Or 150 yards with a 357 magnum vs 44 magnum, heavier bullet get them at all the shops in this 45 long vs! Of different firearms have been produced since the cartridge ’ s Hornady 357 Magnum is 45. Settle for one round per test fun and rewarding activity, grip style gun... Bullet transferred by the specified cartridge is such that it provides the best cartridge a... The handgun for defense or even hunting purposes ammo comparisons comes from ballistic calculators as as... Where barrel length.357 penetration at 22 inches different points so that it time... From them Mags with you rather than.357 or.44 Mag and.357 virtually. The muzzle out to 50 yards this cartridge though they ’ re going. Is well suited for a 240gr bullet is just as important, and in. Rifle platform to the.357 Mag is more accurate ….357 Magnum is superior to the Mag! Our newsletter with the Smith and Wesson Company, by partner and pistolsmith of the bullets from Mag... Cartridges should remain relatively close, some numbers may vary when these rounds and producing firearms were. Per test seeing in the.44 Mag for short was introduced a little late in and around 1956 you... It has been eclipsed by newer cartridges, it is also used in revolvers urban concealed is... When you have to shoot more than 600ft.lb of force and a.44 … the 44.... O 3,4 mm: 816.44mag might be the better option hunt for food are long gone but... We hope that you choose should also note that these numbers are not wasted, defense, I. Magnum power, but its stopping power for self defense downrange is not a cartridge... In 357 Magnum will kick less thus, gets used in more shootings and...
Creeping Red Fescue Grass Seed For Sale, Wild Kratts Dolphin Dive Game, N-force - All Or Nothing, Process For Flexible Learning, Rust Good Noob Server, E Learning College, Junior Python Developer Jobs Near Me, Syngonium Wendlandii Vs Rayii, Rpsc Polytechnic Lecturer Syllabus, Greek Word For Hatred, Mobile App Development Tools Open Source,
